a world of stereotypes

There was an interesting piece of news recently about a Mexican postage stamp portraying a popular black Mexican cartoon character famous in a series of comic books. According to my husband, who is Mexican, the character, named Mimin Pinguin, is totally innocuous, very family-oriented, perhaps a bit precocious, but in general portrayed in a very positive light in the books. In the last few weeks, however, black activists such as the Rev. Jesse Jackson have been in an “uproar,” suggesting that the stamp is racist and stereotypical. The Mexican government has refused to apologize, stating that the American activists don’t understand Mexican culture and are totally misunderstanding the character.

I thought this was interesting, because although the character is drawn in caricature, with large lips, a large head and a lanky body, this cannot be the basis for the offense, can it? I mean, how many times are white people caricatured with big noses? Can George W. be pissed off every time a newspaper cartoonists draws him with enormous ears?! I was thinking about whether my assessment was too shallow, and if there is somehow something more sinister about caricatures of people of color than of whites. I don’t know.

As a middle class child of the ’80s, I was taught to treat everyone equally, but at the same time, my parents and other adults I knew growing up defined the differences between people indirectly by their comments and actions. My parents are by no means racist, but their lives are obviously much closer to the Civil Rights movement, and they can remember something from before it. I grew up in the mostly white suburbs, but have since lived in the city and have always worked with a lot of diverse people. I know I am by no means a perfectly accepting person, but I think my work experience starting in my teen years made me less quick to stereotype than perhaps my parents, who grew up in a very different Milwaukee than we live in today. This is all to say, I strive to treat people equally, although I know I don’t always. I know that my gut reactions sometimes betray my good intentions, leave it at that.

I have a bit of international experience and try to keep informed about the world. In my exploration of China and indirect knowledge of Mexico, I have realized how unique the “melting pot” nature of our society is. Certainly there are similar situations in Canada and many areas of Europe, but within the U.S. literally live individuals from all over the world. There are communities all over the country of Mexicans, Chinese, Koreans, Somalians, Germans. That list doesn’t even do justice to the diversity of our culture. There is no escaping colliding, co-existing cultures in any urban area today. Increasingly, there are immigrant workers in smaller and smaller towns, even rural areas of our country.

Today, my husband and I were watching a bit of Gone with the Wind on TV, and he commented that the “Mamie” character was similar to the mother of Mimin Pinguin. This took me back a bit. “Mamie” is certainly a noble, good-hearted character in the story, but also the quintessential example of the subservient, master-adoring slave, clearly disdained in one respect by most African-Americans. But as I tried to think about it from the Mexican perspective, the character became totally different. In a society where women still typically take care of the children and household, and where mothers are universally adored, “Mamie” is not a negative character at all. And Memin Pinguin is simply, like all boys, a mischevious, spirited child goofing around with his friends.

So I started to think about how the U.S. is condemning this postage stamp because “a stereotype is a stereotype” and all that jazz. And I started to think, what right do we have to do that? We are increasingly a nation of free-thinking, individualistic, excessively greedy (and overweight) people. We may like our lifestyle, but it certainly has its ups, downs and health risks. A nation like Mexico has never had a Civil Rights movement, and likely never will, because it is basically a homogeneous society of mixed Spanish and Native Indian descent. Perhaps they could come up with a more realistic drawing of Memin Pinguin, but then perhaps we should do away with Speedy Gonzalez, that old Mariachi-singing mouse with the huge sombrero. The double standard is so absurd. My husband and several of the liberal Mexicans whose comments I read online agree that the Mimin Pinguin character has helped Mexicans become less racist, as they are so extremely unlikely to ever meet an actual black person in their life. The fact that the character seems just like any regular Mexican kid with a mother similar to any Mexican mother, puts this particular “stereotype” in a new light.

Advertisements

3 Responses to a world of stereotypes

  1. Jack says:

    Hi Laura, I think you are kind of nibbling around the edges of a real issue
    here, and it is not that blacks are offended by depictions of characters
    like Mimin Pinguin. The issue is that American activists, as you refer to
    them, like Jessie Jackson, retain their influence, power, and money by
    stirring the racial flames at every possible opportunity. What is right or
    fair is not important to people like Jackson and many on the left. What is
    important to them is influence and power, and they retain that by stoking
    the flames on non issues like Mimin Pinguin or the recent comments by
    Vicente Fox regarding the willingness of Mexican workers to take jobs that
    African American workers don’t want.

    The real crime here is that this message of victimhood by the left toward
    the Black community only serves to keep that group beholden to the left,
    and does nothing to help the people in that community improve their
    circumstances.

  2. Laura says:

    Touche, but just because a person (me) identifies with certain political ideas does not mean they should be identified with or presumed to agree with certain extremists (Jesse) from that general side. I am sure you don’t agree with every conservative thinker in America without considering what they are saying; same as I don’t agree with all or even most liberal politicians.

    I wasn’t really making a political statement with my post, although you are right that liberal activists (the Bush administration DID, however, agree that the stamp was in poor taste) have blown this out of proportion. But that wasn’t my point. My point was that this issue made me think more about culture, specifically what happens when Americans and others judge before they have any understanding of other culture.

  3. Michael Tyas says:

    Stereotypes boggle my mind.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: